NATO — McChrystal Assesses Past Year, Looks Ahead

BRUSSELS, Bel­gium — A year to the day after he met here with NATO offi­cials on his way to take com­mand of U.S. and inter­na­tion­al forces in Afghanistan, Army Gen. Stan­ley A. McChrys­tal today reviewed the progress achieved there over the last 12 months and pro­vid­ed his per­spec­tive for the year to come.

McChrys­tal met with reporters at NATO head­quar­ters here, where the alliance’s defense min­is­ters, includ­ing Defense Sec­re­tary Robert M. Gates, are hav­ing two days of meet­ings. Though much remains to be done in Afghanistan, McChrys­tal said, much has tak­en place with a new approach to the mis­sion over the last year. 

“I’m not going to try to tell you that every­thing changed day-to-day,” he said, “because it does not [work] that way, but over the course of the year, it’s been pret­ty significant.” 

The new approach for the Afghanistan mis­sion began with an exhaus­tive assess­ment fol­lowed by refine­ments in strat­e­gy and some dif­fi­cult resource deci­sions, McChrys­tal said. The past year also has seen an over­haul of the command’s con­cept of oper­a­tions, and a retool­ing of how it devel­ops the Afghan nation­al secu­ri­ty forces. 

“[The Afghan forces] are the strate­gic main effort,” he said, “and they are key to the long-term sta­bil­i­ty of the country.” 

Mean­while, the num­bers of Afghan sol­diers and nation­al police con­tin­ue to increase, McChrys­tal said. 

“A year ago, there were about 150,000 total Afghan nation­al secu­ri­ty forces,” he said. “Today, there are 230,000. That’s a sig­nif­i­cant growth in a 12-month peri­od. In 18 months – that 12, plus the next six months – we will have equaled the growth of the last sev­en years, so you can see that pace has accelerated.” 

But num­bers aren’t the whole sto­ry, McChrys­tal said. The qual­i­ty of Afghan forces is mov­ing ahead rapid­ly over the past year through coali­tion forces work­ing side by side with their Afghan partners. 

“Today, about 85 per­cent of the Afghan Nation­al Army has real part­ner­ships as they go around the bat­tle­field,” he said. Though the Afghan forces are many years away from a lev­el of pro­fes­sion­al­ism that would be expect­ed of long-stand­ing forces such as the U.S. Army, the gen­er­al said, they have made sig­nif­i­cant progress. 

Build­ing the Afghan Nation­al Police remains a chal­lenge, McChrys­tal acknowl­edged, not­ing it needs more train­ing and “in many cas­es, does­n’t have as much trust of the pop­u­lace that a police force must have.” 

“And we rec­og­nize those chal­lenges, and are work­ing to improve,” the gen­er­al said. 

That recog­ni­tion shows through in a greater than 400 per­cent increase in nation­al police offi­cer train­ing over the past year, McChrys­tal not­ed. A year ago, he added, few Afghan police had received any for­mal training. 

“If you recall,” McChrys­tal said, “we had a ‘recruit, deploy, train’ mod­el. Today, only about 50 per­cent of them have had for­mal train­ing, but that’s sig­nif­i­cant­ly up from 12 months ago, and we are now in a ‘recruit, train, deploy’ model. 

“And we are going back to pick up deployed police as well,” he added. “That will take time, but that has a sig­nif­i­cant impact.” 

Oper­a­tional­ly, the focus over the past year has been in south­ern Afghanistan, par­tic­u­lar­ly in Hel­mand province, where the Tal­iban owned most of the Hel­mand Riv­er val­ley a year ago, McChrys­tal said. “In ear­ly July,” he said, “we start­ed putting forces down there to aug­ment the small num­ber that had been there, and [the Tal­iban] don’t own the H

elmand Riv­er val­ley any more.” Yet, chal­lenges remain in Hel­mand province, McChrys­tal acknowl­edged, not­ing that insur­gent-com­mit­ted vio­lence there has con­tin­ued and will continue. 

“It is by no means a com­plete­ly secure area,” he said. “But a year ago, when they owned it, is stark­ly dif­fer­ent from what exists now.” 

When he took charge in Afghanistan, McChrys­tal said, he was unsat­is­fied with the struc­ture and uni­ty of com­mand of the orga­ni­za­tion that was in place. 

“Today, we’ve uni­fied that,” he said. “We’ve cre­at­ed some sub­or­di­nate com­mands, … and we’ve tied our efforts clos­er with the civil­ian side, and [it’s] more inte­grat­ed than in the past, and I’m hap­py with that progress.” 

Close-air sup­port was a lead­ing cause of civil­ian casu­al­ties in Afghanistan a year ago, McChrys­tal said, and a sus­tained focus on that prob­lem has reduced it.

“And Afghans see that,” he added, “and some of the feed­back I get from Afghans is appre­ci­a­tion for that. We still have more to do to try to bring civil­ian casu­al­ties by all mea­sures as low as we can, but we’ve made real progress in parts of that.” 

Anoth­er mark of progress, McChrys­tal said, is that deten­tion oper­a­tions are on track to come under Afghan con­trol. “The deputy com­man­der of our Joint Task Force 435 is an Afghan offi­cer,” he said, “and we’re on track to hand over all deten­tion oper­a­tions at the deten­tion facil­i­ty in Par­wan to Afghans in Jan­u­ary 2011 — and that will con­sti­tute all of our deten­tion operations.” 

Spe­cial oper­a­tions forces in Afghanistan a year ago were about a third of what they are now, McChrys­tal said, and in the last 90 days, 121 Tal­iban lead­ers have been cap­tured around the country. 

“Even in a pop­u­la­tion-cen­tric [coun­terin­sur­gency] cam­paign, you must have all the aspects,” he said. “You must have that part to tar­get key ene­my lead­ers, you must also have that part which pro­tects the pop­u­la­tion, and then, of course, the crit­i­cal gov­ern­ment and devel­op­men­tal parts. But this is a sig­nif­i­cant piece of what we’re doing.” 

Region­al­ly, McChrys­tal said, coop­er­a­tion has improved sig­nif­i­cant­ly with Pak­istan. “We’ve estab­lished new bor­der coor­di­na­tion cen­ters,” he said. “We’ve renewed the tri­par­tite con­fer­ence struc­ture that we use, and we’ve increased and improved rela­tion­ships at all lev­els, with their forces, primarily.” 

Sum­ma­riz­ing the past year, McChrys­tal said it has “put us in a posi­tion to make progress.” 

As forces have built up in Hel­mand province “where we’ve been the longest, we’ve seen the most progress,” the gen­er­al said. Look­ing ahead, he added, the Afghans will have to be increas­ing­ly involved in the province for that progress to continue. 

“We see progress every­where,” the gen­er­al said, “but it’s still incom­plete. It’ll take time, and it’ll require us to con­sol­i­date gains. And impor­tant­ly, it will require our Afghan part­ners to be part of that at each step of the way – both the police [and] the army, and then, of course, the gov­er­nance and devel­op­ment aspects as they rebuild Afghan con­trol of an area that they essen­tial­ly have not con­trolled for a num­ber of years.” 

Oper­a­tions under way around Kan­da­har today could­n’t be done a year ago, McChrys­tal said. 

“We’ve begun exten­sive plan­ning and shap­ing oper­a­tions, and that’s ongo­ing,” he said. “Our force uplift is expand­ing our abil­i­ty to secure and clear, and secu­ri­ty forces con­tin­ue to arrive. A year ago, there were about 7,300 total forces in Kan­da­har City and the envi­rons, and those are the key dis­tricts con­tigu­ous to the city. By the end of August, we’ll have about 20,300 forces in that same area.” 

McChrys­tal said he’ll accom­pa­ny Afghan Pres­i­dent Hamid Karzai as he con­ducts anoth­er in a series of “shuras,” or meet­ings of com­mu­ni­ty lead­ers, in Kan­da­har in the next few days. Karzai will “be focus­ing on all things to improve in Kan­da­har: secu­ri­ty, gov­er­nance, reduc­ing cor­rup­tion, [and] increas­ing capac­i­ty of Afghan gov­er­nance and devel­op­ment there,” the gen­er­al said. “We also will be look­ing at con­tract­ing reform, pri­vate secu­ri­ty com­pa­nies and what we can do with land dis­putes [that] under­lie many of the problems.” 

The past year has seen progress in devel­op­ing con­cepts and a pro­gram for rec­on­cil­i­a­tion and rein­te­gra­tion of Afghans who had pre­vi­ous­ly sided with the Tal­iban or oth­er dis­rup­tive ele­ments, McChrys­tal said. 

“The recent con­sul­ta­tive peace jir­ga rep­re­sent­ed an event in that process to bring nation­al con­sen­sus to it,” he said, “and I think it was an impor­tant step to explain and bring the Afghan peo­ple toward more inclu­sive gov­er­nance and bring­ing dia­logue on rein­te­gra­tion back. And I think they gath­ered the thoughts of the peo­ple and got the man­date that they want­ed to move for­ward in those programs.” 

In the year ahead, McChrys­tal said, he envi­sions that the tran­si­tion to Afghan con­trol of cer­tain areas can begin. 

“We view it as a process, and not an event, which enables Afghan own­er­ship and rein­forces Afghan sov­er­eign­ty, and it puts Afghans in the lead and respon­si­ble for their future,” he said. “I don’t think it imme­di­ate­ly reduces the require­ment for inter­na­tion­al-com­mu­ni­ty sup­port of dif­fer­ing kinds, based upon the con­di­tions in each area. 

“In some areas, it will be secu­ri­ty assis­tance,” the gen­er­al con­tin­ued. “In some areas, it will be less mil­i­tary, and it will be more based on help with gov­er­nance and development.” 

McChrys­tal said assess­ing progress involves a detailed process that focus­es on three major areas: the capac­i­ty of Afghanistan’s nation­al gov­ern­ment, growth and devel­op­ment of the Afghan secu­ri­ty forces, and the secu­ri­ty sit­u­a­tion, which means pro­tect­ing the pop­u­la­tion while degrad­ing the insurgency. 

“All three show signs of progress,” the gen­er­al said. “It is slow, but pos­i­tive. It varies from region to region. And in areas where we have oper­at­ed, it typ­i­cal­ly reflects how long effec­tive coun­terin­sur­gency efforts have been applied.” 

Some­times, that progress is mod­est, he acknowl­edged. “But I think it’s impor­tant that the per­cep­tion of the insur­gency hav­ing momen­tum is revers­ing,” he added. 

Vio­lence is up, McChrys­tal said, and it will con­tin­ue to rise, par­tic­u­lar­ly over the sum­mer as forces in Afghanistan roll back Tal­iban influ­ence and move toward increased secu­ri­ty. “Afghan con­fi­dence is improv­ing, and they are a coura­geous and resilient peo­ple,” he said. “But they have been at war for 31 years, or they have been impact­ed by vio­lence for 31 years, and that’s sig­nif­i­cant. They want a bet­ter future, and we think that we’re set­ting con­di­tions for them to shape their future.” 

But suc­cess won’t come quick­ly, the gen­er­al said. 

“Progress won’t show every day,” he said, “but it will show over time, week-by-week and month-by-month. And it will be evident.” 

Oper­a­tions con­duct­ed ear­li­er this year in and around the for­mer Tal­iban strong­hold of Mar­ja pro­vid­ed some lessons that are being applied in and around Kan­da­har, McChrys­tal said, not­ing any deci­sive point in Kan­da­har may come lat­er than orig­i­nal­ly envisioned. 

“We re-adjust our plans about every day, as most mil­i­tary com­man­ders do, because you react to devel­op­ments on the ground,” he said. “We haven’t changed the focus of what we intend to pro­duce around Kan­da­har, nor have we changed the basic force struc­ture. We con­tin­ue to mod­i­fy it. I do think that it will hap­pen more slow­ly than we had orig­i­nal­ly antic­i­pat­ed. “As we con­duct coun­terin­sur­gency oper­a­tions around the coun­try and the Hel­mand Riv­er val­ley,” he con­tin­ued, “we are remind­ed that it’s a delib­er­ate process. It takes time to con­vince peo­ple. … We are already in the process of doing polit­i­cal and mil­i­tary shap­ing, but it’s my per­son­al assess­ment that it will be more delib­er­ate than we thought ear­li­er and communicated.” 

There­fore, the gen­er­al added, oper­a­tions in Kan­da­har will take months to play out. 

“But I don’t think that’s nec­es­sar­i­ly a bad thing,” he added. “I think it’s more impor­tant we get it right than we get it fast.” 

U.S. Depart­ment of Defense
Office of the Assis­tant Sec­re­tary of Defense (Pub­lic Affairs) 

Team GlobDef

Seit 2001 ist im Internet unterwegs, um mit eigenen Analysen, interessanten Kooperationen und umfassenden Informationen für einen spannenden Überblick der Weltlage zu sorgen. war dabei die erste deutschsprachige Internetseite, die mit dem Schwerpunkt Sicherheitspolitik außerhalb von Hochschulen oder Instituten aufgetreten ist.

Alle Beiträge ansehen von Team GlobDef →