Australia — Minister for Defence Stephen Smith on Amphibious ships fleet

TOPICS: Funer­als of the Christ­mas Island boat tragedy vic­tims; Amphibi­ous ships fleet; HMAS Suc­cess Com­mis­sion of Inquiry
KIERAN GILBERT: Defence Min­is­ter, I want to ask you about a speech you gave yes­ter­day and some devel­op­ments in Defence mat­ters. But first and fore­most on this issue of the asy­lum seek­ers, the funer­als yes­ter­day, what do you make of crit­i­cism from Scott Mor­ri­son that the cost was not rea­son­able to fly rel­a­tives to those funer­als?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, I think it is very regret­table and most unfor­tu­nate that Mr Mor­ri­son has cho­sen to effec­tive­ly cre­ate a polit­i­cal con­tro­ver­sy off the back of peo­ple who are griev­ing as a result of the loss of fam­i­ly and loved ones in a ter­ri­ble tragedy.

The only sen­si­ble thing to do in these cir­cum­stances is to apply com­mon sense, under­stand that peo­ple are enti­tled to bury their loved ones in an atmos­phere of civil­i­ty and dig­ni­ty, with as much com­pas­sion as the state or the com­mu­ni­ty can sum­mon. And I think Mr Mor­ri­son has made a very bad mis­take here and that’s been reflect­ed by com­ments to the con­trary that we’ve seen come from his own col­leagues.

KIERAN GILBERT: The Prime Min­is­ter was asked about this yes­ter­day in New Zealand. Ini­tial­ly she said it was a mat­ter for rel­e­vant Min­is­ters. It took her a while to find her voice on this issue. Was she tread­ing a lit­tle bit care­ful­ly because of the pol­i­tics of this? STEPHEN SMITH: No no, she was also asked some ques­tions about my speech and she sen­si­bly said port­fo­lio Min­is­ters are deal­ing with these mat­ters in Aus­tralia, I’m on an over­seas trip.

So that’s a sen­si­ble approach. But I think you’ve seen overnight and this morn­ing a num­ber of things occur. First­ly, I think there would be a gen­er­al­ly held com­mu­ni­ty view that in the after­math of a tragedy of that nature, peo­ple should give every assis­tance that they can to enable loved ones to say a dig­ni­fied farewell at the funer­al of their fam­i­ly mem­bers.

Sec­ond­ly, it’s nev­er sen­si­ble, it’s nev­er a good thing for the com­mu­ni­ty, it’s nev­er a good thing for our coun­try when either delib­er­ate­ly or inad­ver­tent­ly, events like these are politi­cised. It does­n’t help any­one. Invari­ably they rebound and they’ve rebound­ed on Mr Mor­ri­son today. And they’ve rebound­ed on Mr Mor­ri­son because mem­bers of his own polit­i­cal par­ty have made com­pa­ra­ble points to the points that I make.

KIERAN GILBERT: On to Defence mat­ters. You’ve set up an expert advi­so­ry pan­el to assess why the trans­port ships Manoo­ra, Kan­im­bla, and Tobruk were all out of action at the time when the Gov­ern­ment want­ed them to sup­port the response to Cyclone Yasi. You must have been flab­ber­gast­ed that none of them were in oper­a­tion at that time?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, I’ve expressed my dis­ap­point­ment both in pri­vate and in pub­lic, first­ly. Sec­ond­ly, I’ve been very frank with the com­mu­ni­ty with the prob­lem that we have and the need to address it. That’s why I’ve estab­lished an expert inde­pen­dent review team chaired by Mr Riz­zo who’s well expe­ri­enced in such mat­ters. But I’ve also asked Defence to pro­vide for­mal­ly a new tran­si­tion plan for our amphibi­ous or heavy-lift fleet.

These things are dis­ap­point­ing. But as the mate­ri­als and the remarks I made yes­ter­day made clear, they’re prob­lems of long stand­ing. And one of the good ini­tia­tives that the Chief of Navy has effect­ed in recent years has been the Sea­wor­thi­ness Board. It was real­ly the report of the Sea­wor­thi­ness Board into the Manoo­ra and the Kan­im­bla which real­ly brought a focus on these things.

KIERAN GILBERT: So why are you just focus­ing on these three ships then? Should­n’t this pan­el be tasked with look­ing at the Navy across the board?

STEPHEN SMITH: The terms of ref­er­ence and my pub­lic remarks make it clear that what­ev­er lessons we learn from this in terms of changes that we need to make for the main­te­nance and sus­tain­ment of our amphibi­ous fleet, any lessons that we learn which apply more gen­er­al­ly will be utilised.

Our heavy amphibi­ous lift is required for two rea­sons. One, the obvi­ous mil­i­tary trans­porta­tion, but sec­ond­ly for dis­as­ter relief and human­i­tar­i­an assis­tance. And in recent weeks I have indi­cat­ed to our Unit­ed King­dom coun­ter­parts and col­leagues that we’re very inter­est­ed in either leas­ing or buy­ing one of their amphibi­ous lift fleet. And also when I was in New Zealand last week, reaf­firmed by the two Prime Min­is­ters yes­ter­day, a much enhanced shared arrange­ment so far as the use of a New Zealand amphibi­ous lift ship, the HMNZS Can­ter­bury, is con­cerned. And that will apply for region­al dis­as­ter relief and devel­op­ment assis­tance.

KIERAN GILBERT: Giv­en the amount of mon­ey that goes into Defence though, the fact that the three amphibi­ous ves­sels, we had all three of them out of action, it seems remark­able. Is this a dys­func­tion­al part of the mil­i­tary that we’re talk­ing about here?

STEPHEN SMITH: I’ve made it very clear that there is clear­ly a cul­tur­al prob­lem here. There seems to have been over a long peri­od of time, more than a decade, a decade and a half, a view that in some respects these were sec­ond-class ships. They weren’t giv­en the pri­or­i­ty that they deserved. We also have, in my view, sig­nif­i­cant per­son­nel and insti­tu­tion­al account­abil­i­ty issues in Defence. And in my speech yes­ter­day I indi­cate that I yes­ter­day received from Dr Rufus Black his review into account­abil­i­ty — per­son­nel and insti­tu­tion­al account­abil­i­ty – which will form a very sig­nif­i­cant fea­ture of the reforms that I will roll out in the next few months.

There’s also a lag effect here. I made the point yes­ter­day the Chief of Navy is to be com­pli­ment­ed for estab­lish­ing the Sea­wor­thi­ness Board. That was inevitably going to draw atten­tion to dif­fi­cul­ties of the past. But one of the good things we hope and are con­fi­dent in is that will be a sig­nif­i­cant fac­tor in help­ing to ensure that this sit­u­a­tion nev­er emerges again.

KIERAN GILBERT: And Min­is­ter, just final­ly, I under­stand you’ve got an update for us on the report into alleged mis­con­duct aboard HMAS Suc­cess. STEPHEN SMITH: I’ve indi­cat­ed that I want to make that report from Com­mis­sion­er Gyles pub­lic. But I have to be very care­ful about the way in which that is done to pro­tect people’s indi­vid­ual and per­son­al rights. I’ll be in a posi­tion to release sub­stan­tial parts of that report ear­ly next week. And I’ll do that when the Par­lia­ment resumes in the first part of next week.

KIERAN GILBERT: Okay, Defence Min­is­ter, appre­ci­ate your time, thanks.

STEPHEN SMITH: Thank you, thank you very much.

Press release
Min­is­te­r­i­al Sup­port and Pub­lic Affairs,
Depart­ment of Defence,
Can­ber­ra, Aus­tralia

More news and arti­cles can be found on Face­book and Twit­ter.

Fol­low GlobalDefence.net on Face­book and/or on Twit­ter

Team GlobDef

Team GlobDef

Seit 2001 ist GlobalDefence.net im Internet unterwegs, um mit eigenen Analysen, interessanten Kooperationen und umfassenden Informationen für einen spannenden Überblick der Weltlage zu sorgen. GlobalDefenc.net war dabei die erste deutschsprachige Internetseite, die mit dem Schwerpunkt Sicherheitspolitik außerhalb von Hochschulen oder Instituten aufgetreten ist.

Alle Beiträge ansehen von Team GlobDef →