Afghanistan — Officials Explain Afghanistan’s Complexity

WASHINGTON, April 13, 2010 — The hur­dles to be over­come in Afghanistan are no sim­ple mat­ter, the direc­tor of com­mu­ni­ca­tions for NATO and U.S. forces there told reporters trav­el­ing with Navy Adm. Mike Mullen when the chair­man of the Joint Chiefs of Staff vis­it­ed ear­li­er this month.
“Afghanistan is a com­pli­cat­ed place,” Navy Rear Adm. Greg Smith said. 

Smith and oth­ers work­ing in Kab­ul spoke of the com­plex “human ter­rain” of Afghanistan and the chal­lenges fac­ing the coali­tion as forces work to pro­vide secu­ri­ty and to train Afghans to take over respon­si­bil­i­ty for the mission. 

Know­ing the play­ers and how they relate to each oth­er is tremen­dous­ly impor­tant, Smith said. The fam­i­ly is the cen­ter of life in the nation, he explained — not the nuclear fam­i­ly of West­ern thought, but the extend­ed fam­i­ly of aunts, uncles, cousins twice-removed, and so on. 

Fam­i­lies form the basis of the country’s trib­al cul­ture. Trib­al lead­ers are the law-givers and judges in most rur­al parts of the coun­try, the admi­ral said. Each town has trib­al elders who work togeth­er to run the area. The con­cept goes back to an ear­li­er time, and these tra­di­tion­al ties are impor­tant to the very tra­di­tion­al population. 

In many parts of the coun­try, it is a world lit only by fire. Scenes of vil­lage life seem unchanged from bib­li­cal times. Afghanistan has an agrar­i­an econ­o­my, with lit­tle evi­dence of progress in plant­i­ng, fer­til­iz­ing and irri­ga­tion tech­niques. On the sur­face, it’s as if 2,000 years just did­n’t hap­pen. Blood feuds can last through gen­er­a­tions. In win­ter, the ani­mals live in the homes with the fam­i­lies. The lit­er­a­cy rate is about 28 per­cent for men and 5 per­cent for women. 

A bazaar with men slaugh­ter­ing lambs on one side of the street will have a stall sell­ing cell phones on the oth­er. Straight down the mid­dle of the street trav­els a motor­cy­cle with three young men on it. The peo­ple want schools and med­ical facil­i­ties and roads – and they want them now. 

And the way to do it, Smith said, is through build­ing on tra­di­tion­al Afghan meth­ods. Shuras are the way the peo­ple get their con­cerns aired and dis­cussed and act­ed upon. The shu­ra is like a New Eng­land town meet­ing, where all can come and speak. The lead­ers of the local shuras then move to dis­trict meet­ings, and so on up the line “This is how gov­er­nance is done in south­ern Afghanistan,” said Frank Rug­giero, the top U.S. civil­ian offi­cial in that region. 

No con­sti­tu­tion gov­erns how shuras are com­posed or when they must be held. A shu­ra can be tru­ly rep­re­sen­ta­tive of an area, Rug­giero explained, or it can be manip­u­lat­ed by war­lords, elders or trib­al lead­ers. “The more [peo­ple] you include, the more like­ly there will be a body address­ing the com­plaints of the peo­ple,” he said. But the tra­di­tion­al process has prob­lems, he said. In some parts of the coun­try, 30-plus years of war has oblit­er­at­ed the tra­di­tion­al ways of doing things and the peo­ple who could imple­ment them. In oth­ers, cer­tain tribes have tak­en over the process and frozen out peo­ple from oth­er tribes. 

Gen­er­al­ly, Rug­giero said, the areas with work­able shu­ra sys­tems had good con­tacts with the provin­cial and nation­al gov­ern­ment. Oth­er areas, he added, “are the areas sus­cep­ti­ble to Tal­iban intim­i­da­tion and rule.” 

Shuras are the way for­ward, Rug­giero said, and secu­ri­ty is nec­es­sary for the sys­tem to work. “The tribes on the fence want secu­ri­ty, access to jus­tice and eco­nom­ic activ­i­ty,” he explained. “If you pro­vide those things, the tribes on the fence will be less sup­port­ive of the Taliban.” 

Offi­cials through­out south­ern Afghanistan referred to a “thirst for secu­ri­ty” in the region. If the nation­al and provin­cial gov­ern­ment can’t or won’t pro­vide it, a senior mil­i­tary offi­cial said, speak­ing on back­ground, the peo­ple will turn to the Tal­iban. “If it’s a choice between a bru­tal war­lord or a cor­rupt offi­cial or a police chief that’s shak­ing them down or the Tal­iban,” he explained, they’ll opt for the Tal­iban, because they can deal with the Taliban.” 

That’s because the Tal­iban are over­whelm­ing­ly local, he explained. “Three quar­ters of Tal­iban fight with­in just a cou­ple of miles from their homes,” he said. 

The prob­lem, offi­cials said, comes down to a lack of gov­ern­ment capac­i­ty to pro­vide ser­vices. The pop­u­la­tion is dis­en­fran­chised, and the lack of good gov­er­nance con­tributes to this prob­lem. Local, provin­cial and nation­al gov­ern­ment has only spot­ty suc­cess in estab­lish­ing the rule of law and jus­tice and in deliv­er­ing basic ser­vices. If the gov­ern­ment can­not do this, offi­cials said, var­i­ous pow­er bro­kers will step in and fill the vacuum. 

Giv­en that secu­ri­ty is nec­es­sary for progress, train­ing the Afghan secu­ri­ty forces is a pri­or­i­ty for coali­tion forces. Police have a ter­ri­ble rep­u­ta­tion in Afghanistan; offi­cials in Kab­ul and Kan­da­har said the police were “tak­en off the street, giv­en a badge and told to police the area,” an offi­cial said. The pay was not enough to sup­port a fam­i­ly, so the local police turned to extor­tion to make up the difference. 

In Mar­ja, the site of the lat­est offen­sive against the insur­gents, the peo­ple insist­ed that the gov­ern­ment get the cor­rupt local police out of the area as one of the pre­con­di­tions for allow­ing oper­a­tions to take place. 

Oper­a­tions in Mar­ja, and now in Kan­da­har, are con­duct­ed by Afghan Civ­il Order Police – a nation­al force based on the Ital­ian Cara­biniere mod­el — and the peo­ple trust them. The train­ing effort in Afghanistan also is address­ing the short­falls in the police, and offi­cers now must be trained before walk­ing the beat. In addi­tion, the police now have pay par­i­ty with the Afghan army. 

U.S. Depart­ment of Defense
Office of the Assis­tant Sec­re­tary of Defense (Pub­lic Affairs) 

Team GlobDef

Seit 2001 ist im Internet unterwegs, um mit eigenen Analysen, interessanten Kooperationen und umfassenden Informationen für einen spannenden Überblick der Weltlage zu sorgen. war dabei die erste deutschsprachige Internetseite, die mit dem Schwerpunkt Sicherheitspolitik außerhalb von Hochschulen oder Instituten aufgetreten ist.

Alle Beiträge ansehen von Team GlobDef →