Australian Minister for Defence on Libya, Facebook and Afghanistan, C‑17 assistance to Japan

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: We’re joined now in the stu­dio by the Defence Min­is­ter Stephen Smith. Stephen Smith, good morn­ing.
STEPHEN SMITH: Good morn­ing.
VIRGINIA TRIOLI: In fact, we’ve been hear­ing from Ban Ki-moon and also from the Pen­ta­gon today about the adverse strat­e­gy at the moment. It would seem like­ly — at least accord­ing to Turkey — that NATO forces will take over com­mand of that oper­a­tion around about next Tues­day. Is that what you’re hear­ing too?
STEPHEN SMITH: Well, I said yes­ter­day that [indis­tinct] thought that would occur, a tran­si­tion effec­tive­ly over the week­end. UK For­eign Sec­re­tary Hague and my UK coun­ter­part, Liam Fox were hav­ing dis­cus­sions with their coun­ter­parts in Lon­don over the week­end.

And so, it’s in some respects a nat­ur­al tran­si­tion. We always believed — Aus­tralia always believed that if the Secu­ri­ty Coun­cil did resolve for a no-fly zone, the appro­pri­ate enforce­ment agent was NATO or con­stituent coun­tries. And I expect we’ll see Unit­ed King­dom, France tak­ing a lead in that respect.

MICHAEL ROWLAND: Does it con­cern you that after sev­en days, there — of airstrikes — com­pre­hen­sive airstrikes both on air defence sys­tems and ground forces, Colonel Qaddafi’s forces are still very much in play in some of the key cities there?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, I was­n’t’ the only per­son who before the Secu­ri­ty Coun­cil resolved for a no-fly zone who said peo­ple need to under­stand this may not be a mag­ic solu­tion to all of the prob­lems on the ground in Libya. 

The Secu­ri­ty Coun­cil res­o­lu­tion itself has as its cen­tre­piece pro­tec­tion of civil­ians; and that’s why you’ve seen enforce­ment action, not just to secure a no-fly zone but also enforce­ment action against on-the-ground assets to stop ongo­ing attacks on civilians. 

But we do have the poten­tial for a stale­mate which is why, as we speak, the Secu­ri­ty Coun­cil is mov­ing again, the Secretary-General’s call to the Secu­ri­ty Coun­cil and to Colonel Qaddafi has been to effect a cease­fire. And there are sug­ges­tions that Colonel Qaddafi’s rep­re­sen­ta­tives and the Opposition’s rep­re­sen­ta­tives may be get­ting togeth­er with the African Union over the week­end. So there is per­haps some small prospect of also some nego­ti­at­ed arrangement. 

But the prospect of a stale­mate was always there and that’s what we’re see­ing. I don’t think there’s going to be a solu­tion, you know, instant­ly. But we’re pleased that the no-fly zone has been pret­ty effec­tive­ly enforced in a small num­ber of days.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Now, turn­ing to this Face­book issue and the behav­iour of some sol­diers in Afghanistan in the insult­ing and the offen­sive com­ments that they’ve made on Face­book Pages; what is it with the cul­ture that seems to be per­me­at­ing not just the Navy, it would seem now, but also the Army as well?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, first point’s the impor­tant one; we should­n’t assume that because we see some bad inci­dents in Navy and some bad inci­dents in the case of Army, that that reflects all of the cul­ture of our defence forces.

Let me deal express­ly with the appalling Face­book episode. I rang Afghan Defence Min­is­ter War­dak last night. I apol­o­gised to him on behalf of Aus­tralia and I made the point to him that the Chief of the Defence Force and the Chief of Army was inves­ti­gat­ing this mat­ter and in all like­li­hood, dis­ci­pli­nary pro­ceed­ings would fol­low. I also made the point to him that I regard­ed this as very much a very regret­table small minority.

He respond­ed as I expect­ed he would, which was that Aus­tralia Defence Force per­son­nel and our dig­gers in Afghanistan are held in the high­est regard and high­est esteem, not just for their fight­ing capa­bil­i­ty, but because of the way in which they engage with the local community.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: But did he go on to say that this might low­er them in the way they’re held in high esteem?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, that was the point I made to him. I said, I’m ring­ing you, Min­is­ter, because I don’t want this to low­er our stand­ing. He said that in his mind, in his own view, it would not, because he appre­ci­at­ed very much and respect­ed very much the way that Aus­tralian sol­diers con­duct them­selves, both in terms of stick­ing to sen­si­ble rules of engage­ment, engag­ing with the local peo­ple, and when things go wrong, fes­s­ing up to them and tak­ing reme­di­al action. 

But this action by a small num­ber of peo­ple is appalling; I con­demn it absolute­ly and every­one should be in no uncer­tain terms that the Chief of Army, Army senior offi­cers in Afghanistan and the Chief of the Defence Force will pur­sue this to the end. And that includes the pos­si­bil­i­ty of dis­ci­pli­nary pro­ceed­ings. It also includes the pos­si­bil­i­ty of peo­ple who are asso­ci­at­ed or involved with this, if they are in Afghanistan, being returned home.

MICHAEL ROWLAND: Dis­ci­pli­nary action is one thing, but there are many peo­ple call­ing for much stronger action than that — these peo­ple involved being drummed out of the Army. Is that some­thing on the table?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, we have to take this step by step. First­ly, as soon as you start talk­ing about dis­ci­pli­nary pro­ce­dures, peo­ple have rights. So there is a prop­er process to go through; there is an inves­ti­ga­tion under way. But in advance of that inves­ti­ga­tion, it’s open to a local com­man­der if he believes that con­duct has occurred — pri­ma facie con­duct has occurred which would war­rant action, he can take it on the ground.

My own view is that we have on its face con­duct of the most appalling kind that brings Army into dis­re­pute and has the poten­tial to bring Aus­tralia itself into dis­re­pute. And as the Chief of Army said overnight — and in my dis­cus­sions with the Defence Force overnight and this morn­ing — it does­n’t reflect the atti­tude of Army, it does­n’t reflect the sorts of atti­tudes, approach­es and response that we want to see from the mod­ern Aus­tralian Army. And I very strong­ly under­line this point; in the main, it absolute­ly does not. One of the rea­sons Army is so appalled is that it flies in the face of very good con­duct by Army and its per­son­nel in Afghanistan and else­where over a long peri­od of time.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Now, Aus­tralia has been close­ly involved in pro­vid­ing sup­port and aid to Japan, of course, through the earth­quake and tsuna­mi cri­sis. What hard­ware do we have there at the moment and when’s it com­ing home?

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, in the course of this week we’ve var­i­ous­ly had three C‑17s there; two of them flew out from Pearce Air­base in Perth, my own home­town and deliv­ered essen­tial­ly some water equip­ment, very heavy water equip­ment for use in the cool­ing of the nuclear reac­tor. Both of those C‑17s are now back in Amber­ley. The C‑17 that we’ve had from the first moment, which deliv­ered the search and res­cue team, is wrap­ping up its activ­i­ties today and will fly back to Aus­tralia in the course of today and tomor­row. And one of the C‑17s that took the water equip­ment, when it returned, brought back with it the kit from the emer­gency res­cue team. So, by the week­end, all of the C‑17s will be back from Japan. 

And I spoke dur­ing the week to my Japan­ese coun­ter­part, Defence Min­is­ter Kitaza­wa, and he was most grate­ful for the effort that we had put in; oth­er than the Unit­ed States, we’re the only one there who had such a heavy air­lift capability.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: [Indis­tinct] We do have that heavy air­lift capa­bil­i­ty and Japan has its own prob­lems now with some irra­di­at­ed food; has Japan asked for any assis­tance in that respect to have, per­haps, food­stuffs and the like flown in by Australia?

STEPHEN SMITH: Not that I am aware.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Does it sur­prise you, they’ve not asked? It sur­pris­es me. It seems like [indis­tinct] need a bit of help here and maybe they’re not-


VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Extend­ing a hand-


VIRGINIA TRIOLI: That would be hap­pi­ly received.

STEPHEN SMITH: Well, in terms of help, I mean, the Prime Min­is­ter, the For­eign Min­is­ter have made it clear that as a gen­er­al propo­si­tion that we stand ready-


STEPHEN SMITH: Will­ing and able to give Japan what­ev­er assis­tance it wants. As you’d expect, I’ve been focussing on how we can assist in terms of defence assets; but the Prime Minister’s made it clear that what­ev­er Japan asks for, we’re ready, will­ing and able to help a coun­try in Asia who in very many respects has been our clos­est friend for a long peri­od of time.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: We’ll just wait for the ques­tion to be asked.


VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Stephen Smith, good to see you; thank you.

STEPHEN SMITH: Thank you. Thanks very much. 

Press release
Min­is­te­r­i­al Sup­port and Pub­lic Affairs,
Depart­ment of Defence,
Can­ber­ra, Australia 

Face­book and/or on Twit­ter

Team GlobDef

Seit 2001 ist im Internet unterwegs, um mit eigenen Analysen, interessanten Kooperationen und umfassenden Informationen für einen spannenden Überblick der Weltlage zu sorgen. war dabei die erste deutschsprachige Internetseite, die mit dem Schwerpunkt Sicherheitspolitik außerhalb von Hochschulen oder Instituten aufgetreten ist.

Alle Beiträge ansehen von Team GlobDef →