Qatar — Alcohol debate shines light on divisions in Qatari society

Del­e­gates to a high-pow­ered inter­na­tion­al sports secu­ri­ty con­fer­ence had a glimpse this week of Qatar’s inter­nal debate about how far the Gulf state should go in meet­ing West­ern and world soc­cer body FIFA demands that offend con­ser­v­a­tive seg­ments of Qatari soci­ety and the roy­al fam­i­ly.

With the debate focused on the avail­abil­i­ty of alco­hol dur­ing the 2022 World Cup, the first ever to be host­ed in the Mid­dle East, del­e­gates watched Qatar 2022 Supreme Com­mit­tee gen­er­al sec­re­tary Has­san al Thawa­di walk a tightrope in a bid to appease all par­ties.

Mr. Al Thawa­di set off alarm bells in his offi­cial address to the 2nd Inter­na­tion­al Sport Secu­ri­ty Con­fer­ence when he ques­tioned the need for the serv­ing of alco­hol in sta­di­ums. Mr. Al Thawadi’s remarks were per­haps mis­tak­en­ly seen as back­track­ing on an ear­li­er pledge that alco­hol would be rel­a­tive­ly freely avail­able dur­ing the World Cup.

“I don’t see the rea­son for it being in the sta­di­um. I’m look­ing at it in terms of Eng­land and look­ing at in terms of every­body else. That is some­thing we are dis­cussing with FIFA … Let’s dis­cuss this with rel­e­vant stake­hold­ers and come up with a plan that wel­comes every­one,” Mr. Al Thawa­di said.

Speak­ing to jour­nal­ists lat­er, Mr. Al Thawa­di insist­ed that alco­hol would be avail­able dur­ing the World Cup. “All I can say is alco­hol will be avail­able – maybe not as freely avail­able as some oth­er coun­tries but it will be avail­able. We plans and as we go along more clar­i­ty will be pro­vid­ed to peo­ple,” he said.

Qatar nev­er promised pub­licly to allow alco­hol in sta­di­um but has insist­ed since win­ning the right to host the World Cup in Decem­ber 2010 that it would allow con­sump­tion of alco­hol in spe­cial­ly des­ig­nat­ed fan zones.

Mr. Al Thawa­di believes that he stands on strong grounds that the alco­hol issue is a safe­ty and a secu­ri­ty issue rather than a cul­tur­al or reli­gious one. FIFA, defend­ing the com­mer­cial rights of its spon­sors, includ­ing Bud­weis­er beer brew­er Anheuser-Busch InBev, has locked horns with the non-Mus­lim hosts of the next two World Cup, Brazil and Rus­sia. Both coun­tries have out­lawed the sale of alco­hol at sport­ing events in a bid to con­trol crowds and pre-empt vio­lence.

Qatar’s reluc­tance to allow alco­hol in sta­di­ums is how­ev­er being increas­ing­ly com­pro­mised by Brazil and Rus­sia cav­ing into West­ern and FIFA demands. A Brazil­ian con­gres­sion­al com­mis­sion caved in ear­li­er this month and approved a World Cup bill ear­li­er this month that would allow the sale of alco­hol in sta­di­ums. The bill still has to be endorsed by the Brazil­ian parliament’s low­er house and sen­ate and then by Pres­i­dent Dil­ma Rouss­eff.

Rus­sia too appears about to give in. Russ­ian soc­cer fed­er­a­tion pres­i­dent Sergey Fursenko recent­ly called for the rein­sti­tu­tion of beer adver­tise­ments in Russ­ian sta­di­ums. Prime Min­is­ter Vladimir Putin told a soc­cer fan that “when the deci­sion was made about sta­di­ums, it came from the best of inten­tions. OK, we’ll return to it again and think about it.”

Nonethe­less, Mr. Al Thawa­di was hedg­ing his bets because the alco­hol issue takes on par­tic­u­lar sig­nif­i­cance in Qatar, the only Mus­lim state besides Sau­di Ara­bia that adheres to the puri­tan con­cepts of Mohammed Abdel Wah­hab. An 18th cen­tu­ry war­rior preach­er, Mr. Abdul Wahhab’s teach­ings are among Islam’s most con­ser­v­a­tive. By and large Qatar has nonethe­less devel­oped a far more lib­er­al approach than is prac­ticed in Sau­di Ara­bia.

Increas­ing­ly, how­ev­er, con­ser­v­a­tive Qataris and some mem­bers of the roy­al fam­i­ly are sig­nalling their dis­sat­is­fac­tion with the course Emir Hamad Bin Khal­i­fa al-Thani sup­port­ed by his wife, Sheikha Mozah bint Nass­er Al Missned, is steer­ing. Some of that crit­i­cism is believed to be trib­al­ly moti­vat­ed because Sheikha Mozah hails from a tribe that tra­di­tion­al­ly opposed the Al Tha­nis.

As a result, the debate about allow­ing alco­hol amounts to far more than a dis­cus­sion about what con­ces­sions Qatar should make to West­ern soc­cer exec­u­tives and FIFA. It is a debate about the future course of the coun­try, the pow­ers of its ruler and its nation­al iden­ti­ty.

The out­come of the debate will not only deter­mine the future of Qatar’s effort to become a glob­al sports hub – a key pil­lar of the nation­al iden­ti­ty Emir Hamad is seek­ing to shape – but also its posi­tion­ing as a for­ward-look­ing spon­sor of change in a region stretch­ing from the Atlantic coast of Africa to the Gulf that is wracked by anti-gov­ern­ment protests and con­vo­lut­ed tran­si­tions to more open soci­eties.

Mr. Al-Wahhab’s puri­tanism con­sti­tutes the cra­dle of Salafism – an Islam­ic trend that prop­a­gates a return to the way of life at the time of Islam’s first 7th cen­tu­ry caliphs and has emerged as a pow­er polit­i­cal force in post-revolt Egypt and else­where in the region. Sau­di Ara­bia recent­ly offi­cial­ly embraced Salafism as a key ele­ment in its soft pow­er strat­e­gy aimed at coun­ter­ing Iran’s per­ceived rev­o­lu­tion­ary Islam­ic appeal as well as the wave of anti-gov­ern­ment protests sweep­ing the Mid­dle East and North Africa. The embrace also con­sti­tutes a response to Qatar’s idio­syn­crat­ic for­eign and domes­tic poli­cies, includ­ing its sup­port for the Mus­lim Broth­er­hood that is wide­ly dis­trust­ed by Sau­di Ara­bia.

The lat­est debate was sparked when a group of row­dy Aus­tralians and New Zealan­ders left a bar on Pearl Qatar Island, home to an esti­mat­ed 41,000 res­i­dents many of whom are expa­tri­ates, alco­hol bot­tles in hand and con­tin­ued drink­ing in a pub­lic space.

Qatar allows drink­ing only in hotel bars rather than in pub­lic spaces. The Decem­ber inci­dent prompt­ed a ban on drink­ing in Pearl Island restau­rants that have since seen their rev­enues drop dra­mat­i­cal­ly.

The Pearl Island inci­dent has embold­ened Qatari crit­ics of alco­hol to argue that the emir’s tol­er­ance vio­lates the country’s con­sti­tu­tions and laws which do not grant him the pre­rog­a­tive to allow its sale or con­sump­tion. In doing so, the crit­ics are implic­it­ly spark­ing a rare debate about the pow­ers of the ruler.

Has­san Al Sayed, a pro­fes­sor of con­sti­tu­tion­al law and for­mer dean of the Col­lege of Law at Qatar Uni­ver­si­ty, charged that there is no Qatari law that allows for the sale of alco­hol and that in fact sev­er­al laws, includ­ing the con­sti­tu­tion, crim­i­nal­ize it. Even “if there is any deci­sion com­ing for exam­ple from the Emir or any depart­ment here (legal­iz­ing alco­hol)… no in fact, this is not okay and this is against the law,” Mr. Al Sayed said.

He said that for Qatar to legal­ly allow the sale and con­sump­tion of alco­hol it must change its con­sti­tu­tion, which in arti­cle 1 stip­u­lates that “Islam is the State’s reli­gion and the Islam­ic Sharia is the main source of its leg­is­la­tions.” Mr. Al Sayed argues that the legal ban applies also to free zones the gov­ern­ment said it would cre­ate for fans attend­ing the 2022 World Cup.

A major­i­ty of Qataris is like­ly to oppose con­sti­tu­tion­al reform out of fear that the coun­try would lose its Islam­ic iden­ti­ty, a key ele­ment in the nation­al iden­ti­ty it is try­ing to shape.

If sports are for Qatar’s lead­ers a key tool in forg­ing nation­al iden­ti­ty and pro­ject­ing Qatar inter­na­tion­al­ly, ban­ning alco­hol is its equiv­a­lent for more con­ser­v­a­tive and nation­al­ist forces in the Gulf state.

“I don’t see a rea­son to have alco­hol. It impacts very neg­a­tive­ly on locals. Locals are not hap­py with it,” The Wall Street Jour­nal quot­ed Qatari writer Abdul Aziz Al Mah­moud as say­ing.

Con­ser­v­a­tive Qataris wor­ry that an increas­ing num­ber of their com­pa­tri­ots, often dressed in full-length robes, the Gulf’s nation­al dress, drink pub­licly in hotels and bars. “It is a taboo in Qatar to see some­body wear­ing the nation­al dress and drink­ing,” said Has­san Al Ibrahim, a Qatari com­men­ta­tor, accord­ing to the Jour­nal.

Con­ser­v­a­tive fears in a nation where locals account for at best one third of the pop­u­la­tion were fur­ther inflamed when the Qatar Dis­tri­b­u­tion Com­pa­ny, a Qatar Air­ways owned-retail shop, intro­duced pork along­side the alco­hol it was already sell­ing to expa­tri­ates. The intro­duc­tion was one spark of an online call to boy­cott the air­line. It fol­lowed a sim­i­lar protest in recent months decry­ing telecom­mu­ni­ca­tions ser­vices.

“I nev­er thought the day would come that I have to ask the wait­er in a restau­rant in Qatar what kind of meat is in their burg­ers,” said a Qatari on Twit­ter.

“Ppl don’t get it. Its not about the pork—its about us feel­ing more & more like a minority—in our own coun­try,” tweet­ed anoth­er Qatari.

The sense of being a minor­i­ty in one’s own coun­try prompt­ed the Supreme Edu­ca­tion Coun­cil to recent­ly order all edu­ca­tion­al insti­tu­tions to impose Arab as the lan­guage of teach­ing with­in nine months.

The order came after Qatari crown prince Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad bin Khal­i­fa Al-Thani attend­ed a grad­u­a­tion cer­e­mo­ny last fall and not­ed that the major­i­ty of grad­u­ates were not Qataris but for­eign­ers. “Where are the Qataris7 Sheikh Tamim asked.

Aca­d­e­mics attribute the lack of male Qatari stu­dents to the fact that local head hunters hunt Qataris in high school offer­ing them salaries that are the equiv­a­lent to what they would earn once they com­plete a uni­ver­si­ty study. “There is no need for them to study,” a for­eign pro­fes­sor said.

Sheikh Tamim is wide­ly viewed as sym­pa­thet­ic to the con­ser­v­a­tive ele­ment of Qatari soci­ety. Hotels in Qatar that he owns are among those that do not serve alco­hol.

About The Author:
James M. Dorsey is a senior fel­low at the S. Rajarat­nam School of Inter­na­tion­al Stud­ies at Nanyang Tech­no­log­i­cal Uni­ver­si­ty in Sin­ga­pore and the author of the blog, The Tur­bu­lent World of Mid­dle East Soc­cer.

Team GlobDef

Team GlobDef

Seit 2001 ist GlobalDefence.net im Internet unterwegs, um mit eigenen Analysen, interessanten Kooperationen und umfassenden Informationen für einen spannenden Überblick der Weltlage zu sorgen. GlobalDefenc.net war dabei die erste deutschsprachige Internetseite, die mit dem Schwerpunkt Sicherheitspolitik außerhalb von Hochschulen oder Instituten aufgetreten ist.

Alle Beiträge ansehen von Team GlobDef →