Playing with fire: Gulf Arabs and Israelis tacitly explore cooperation amid Israeli diplomatic tsunami

Amid the diplo­mat­ic tsuna­mi hit­ting Israel with its embassy in Cairo stormed by pro­test­ers, its rela­tions with Turkey at an all-time low, the Unit­ed Nations set to rec­og­nize Pales­tin­ian state­hood and the influ­ence of the Unit­ed States, its clos­est ally, sub­stan­tial­ly dimin­ished, con­ser­v­a­tive Gulf states and Israel are qui­et­ly explor­ing com­mon ground. 

Both Israel and the Gulf states are eager to curb the ten month-old wave of anti-gov­ern­ment protests sweep­ing the Mid­dle East and North Africa that have already top­pled the lead­ers of Tunisia, Egypt and Libya and are shak­ing the fun­da­ments of auto­crat­ic regimes in Syr­ia and Yemen. 

Sim­i­lar­ly, the storm­ing this week­end of the Israeli embassy in Cairo by pro­test­ers led by mil­i­tant soc­cer fans rais­es the specter of the rule of the street, send­ing chills down the spine of Israeli and Gulf lead­ers. If Israel’s ambas­sador to Turkey was last week expelled by the gov­ern­ment, Israel’s ambas­sador to Egypt was dri­ven out of the coun­try by pro­test­ers against the will of their rulers. 

Israel and the Gulf states are also wor­ried about the emer­gence of Egypt’s Sinai desert as a large­ly aban­doned fron­tier for weapons smug­gling and human traf­fick­ing that could become a launch­ing pad for attacks on Israel along­side the Gaza Strip that is con­trolled by Hamas, the mil­i­tant Pales­tin­ian Islamist group. This weekend’s storm­ing of the Israeli embassy fol­lowed last month’s killing of five Egypt­ian sol­diers in a bor­der skir­mish sparked by a cross-bor­der attack on an Israeli bus. 

Lost in the focus on the storm­ing of the Israeli embassy with its poten­tial impli­ca­tions for the prospects of Israeli-Pales­tin­ian peace was the fact that the near­by Sau­di embassy was tar­get­ed too. The pro­test­ers vent­ed their anger at the treat­ment of Egypt­ian pil­grims return­ing from the holy city of Mec­ca, who had been delayed at Jed­dah air­port for days and insult­ed by Sau­di air­port offi­cials for putting oust­ed Pres­i­dent Mubarak on tri­al for respon­si­bil­i­ty for the deaths of hun­dreds killed in the protests ear­ly this year that forced him out of office. In a tell­tale sign, Gulf tele­vi­sion sta­tions, includ­ing Al Jazeera, ini­tial­ly offered lim­it­ed cov­er­age of the protests in front of the embassies and launched into live cov­er­age only when the extent of the demon­stra­tions could no longer be ignored. 

Final­ly, Israel and the Gulf states both see Iran as a major threat to region­al sta­bil­i­ty and do not want to see the Islam­ic repub­lic suc­ceed in its alleged efforts to devel­op a nuclear weapons capability. 

If the protests against the Israeli and Sau­di embassies com­pli­cate the feel­ers being put out by Gulf states and Israel, it ben­e­fits, in a per­verse twist of log­ic, Egypt’s rul­ing Supreme Coun­cil of the Armed Forces (SCAF) despite the pro­test­ers chant­i­ng of slo­gans that demand­ed an end to mil­i­tary rule and com­pared SCAF head Field Mar­shal Mohamed Tanta­wi to Mr. Mubarak. 

The storm­ing of the Israeli embassy in par­tic­u­lar shifts the focus of atten­tion to Israel and away from mount­ing dis­con­tent with the con­tin­ued use of mil­i­tary tri­bunals for civil­ians, the con­vo­lu­tions in the tri­al against Mr. Mubarak tri­al, the com­plex nego­ti­a­tions to draft an elec­toral law and the military’s fail­ure to set dates for par­lia­men­tary elec­tions. The embassy inci­dents fur­ther weak­en anti-mil­i­tary oppo­si­tion by dri­ving a wedge among the pro­test­ers with lib­er­als warn­ing that the pop­u­lar revolt was reel­ing out of control. 

In many ways, Turkey’s tough stance on Israel – low­er­ing of diplo­mat­ic rela­tions, sus­pend­ing mil­i­tary ties and pledg­ing to have Turk­ish war­ships escort future aid ships attempt­ing to break the Israeli block­ade of Gaza – has put Egypt and oth­er Arab states on the line. It is like­ly to com­pli­cate any Gulf effort to tac­it­ly coop­er­ate with Israel in fur­ther­ing per­ceived com­mon inter­ests. Egypt, the Gulf lead­ers and oth­er Arab rulers will find it dif­fi­cult to be seen as tak­ing a less firm stand against Israel than non-Arab Turkey and fear that fail­ure to do so could fuel pub­lic discontent. 

Nonethe­less, Dubai’s Khaleej Times pub­lished days after the announce­ment of Turkey’s tougher stance towards Israel and on the day that Israeli embassy staff fled Egypt a rel­a­tive­ly rare op-ed piece writ­ten by an Israeli busi­ness­woman and for­mer for­eign min­istry offi­cial that described the lack of com­mer­cial, eco­nom­ic and tech­ni­cal coop­er­a­tion between Israel and its Arab neigh­bors as a “lose-lose sit­u­a­tion for everyone.” 

Naa­va Mashiah argued that “Israel has been spear­head­ing research and inno­va­tion to over­come a harsh cli­mate and water scarci­ty. But there is very lit­tle knowl­edge shar­ing between Israel and oth­er coun­tries in the MENA (Mid­dle East and North Africa) region. Although food secu­ri­ty would best be addressed in the frame­work of a region­al peace, the absence of such peace between Israel and its neigh­bors should not get in the way of coop­er­a­tion on this issue, giv­en how crit­i­cal the sit­u­a­tion fac­ing the region is.” 

Ms. Mashiah’s com­ments played on Arab con­cerns that ris­ing food prices were a key fac­tor in prompt­ing Arabs across the region to take to the streets. She not­ed that the Arab world imports 50 per cent of its food require­ments and need to become self-suf­fi­cient and less depen­dent on volatile world mar­kets despite the fact that they have lim­it­ed arable land and a short­age of water supplies. 

“Israel, for its part, has made much progress in crop yields, green hous­es tech­nolo­gies, seed acclima­ti­za­tion, drip irri­ga­tion, dew col­lec­tors, waste-water man­age­ment and oth­er unique water tech­nol­o­gy inno­va­tions. Shouldn’t the suc­cess­ful results of high crop yields in arid cli­mates be shared amongst oth­er coun­tries in the region? Time is a big fac­tor. R&D invest­ment is time con­sum­ing and start­ing research from scratch is not the same as ben­e­fit­ting from pre­vi­ous dis­cov­er­ies. De-nation­al­iz­ing tech­nolo­gies and shar­ing knowl­edge is the way for­ward. The soon­er we real­ize this, the bet­ter we can deal with the urgent chal­lenge that all coun­tries of this region share,” Ms. Mashiah wrote. 

Israel and the Gulf states no doubt share a host of com­mon polit­i­cal and eco­nom­ic inter­ests. Yet, the oppor­tu­ni­ty to cap­i­tal­ize on that com­mu­nal­i­ty is shrink­ing at the very moment that they would ben­e­fit most from increased coop­er­a­tion. Nonethe­less, the risks involved in tak­ing those feel­ers a step fur­ther grow by the day as the fall­out of Turkey’s move becomes increas­ing­ly appar­ent and emo­tions take a front seat as the Pales­tini­ans gear up in the Unit­ed Nation for recog­ni­tion of their state­hood in what is like­ly be a large­ly sym­bol­ic vic­to­ry, but one that could dra­mat­i­cal­ly change the legal play­ing field on which Israelis and Pales­tini­ans fight their battles. 

About The Author:
James M. Dorsey is a senior fel­low at the S. Rajarat­nam School of Inter­na­tion­al Stud­ies at Nanyang Tech­no­log­i­cal Uni­ver­si­ty in Sin­ga­pore and the author of the blog, The Tur­bu­lent World of Mid­dle East Soc­cer.

Face­book and/or on Twit­ter

Team GlobDef

Seit 2001 ist im Internet unterwegs, um mit eigenen Analysen, interessanten Kooperationen und umfassenden Informationen für einen spannenden Überblick der Weltlage zu sorgen. war dabei die erste deutschsprachige Internetseite, die mit dem Schwerpunkt Sicherheitspolitik außerhalb von Hochschulen oder Instituten aufgetreten ist.

Alle Beiträge ansehen von Team GlobDef →